Citizens United v. FEC and the Midterms

When we looked at the recent (2010) decision handed down from the Roberts Supreme Court, we were essentially looking at the Constitution and asking "who is a person?"  This decision holds that corporations and political organizations are "people" according to our founding document and therefore have freedom of speech, including "speaking" with their money.



What are you thoughts on this recent shift our political system.  What do you see are the pros and cons of the Citizens United impact.  Do you see an impact in the midterms races?  Do you think it will change any election outcomes?  For better or worse?

[Note: As I find new material for blog posts, it will be added.  It does not change your minimum expectation of 1 educated comment per week, but instead offers you options.  Feel free to comment more and please keep the conversation going.]

Midterm Elections 2010

In case you weren't following, this video provides a basic (and very rapid) overview of significant events influencing the upcoming election.



To understand the big picture of the upcoming congressional elections, it helps to look at maps showing several polls simultaneously, such as this one from CBS News or this one from the New York Times.

Check out the polls, especially in Wisconsin and the "toss up" states.  Next week we can see just how much the media and the electorate knew about the elections before voting ever took place.

An Anti-Politician Politician?

We've discussed this campaign ad in class briefly.  How do you think it relates to polls?  How does this ad reflect the widely reported anti-incumbent mood in the United States this election season?   Could it be that political polling actually increased this sentiment over the past few months?  Make connections between this campaign in which anti-incumbent Ron Johnson has a lead over Russ Feingold or other national campaigns across the country.  How do you see polls reflecting American opinion, and where you view polls influencing public opinion?

Snyder v. Phelps

Snyder v. Phelps (2010)



Watch this discussion of the current SCOTUS case, Snyder v. Phelps on the PBS News Hour.
Oyez.org - Snyder v. Phelps
SCOTUSblog - Snyder v. Phelps main page and Argument Preview (class handout)

While the case may divide American emotionally over the issue of homosexuality, the case being decided is a more fundamental question of free speech vs. privacy.  Remember, basic constitutional civil liberties can often conflict.

What do you think are the best arguments for each side?  How does the precedent on privacy set by Griswold v. Connecticut (1965) connect to this case?  What about cases protecting free speech, such as Hustler v. Falwell (1988)? What do you think the outcome will be?  Discuss connections to class and other thoughts you have on the case.